What China Can Do To Revitalize Its Economy: Challenges Ahead
Written on
Chapter 1: Current Economic Challenges in China
The Chinese economy is experiencing a significant downturn. The stock and real estate markets are consistently declining, debt levels relative to GDP are rising, local governments are nearing bankruptcy, and millions of citizens are struggling to find employment. Is there a way for China to reverse this troubling trend before it’s too late?
One conventional approach to swiftly rejuvenate a faltering economy includes several key strategies:
- Easing monetary policy (such as lowering interest rates and implementing quantitative easing).
- Boosting government expenditures.
- Depreciating the national currency to enhance export competitiveness.
These measures aim to increase consumer spending, stimulate credit growth, elevate asset prices, and combat deflation.
Section 1.1: The Constraints of China’s Banking System
China's current policy interest rate stands at a moderate 3.35%. This level provides some room for monetary easing, although it may soon approach the zero lower bound. However, for reduced interest rates to effectively stimulate credit growth and spending, banks must operate freely and without restrictions, as they are the conduit through which lower rates lead to increased lending.
Contrarily, China's banking system is heavily state-controlled. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) essentially dictates lending practices, determining which entities receive loans and in what amounts. For an extended period, banks have been directed to lend to local governments and favored companies connected to the CCP, financing projects that have since lost their value, such as extravagant infrastructure and real estate developments.
As these local authorities and dubious companies face potential default, the CCP has instructed banks to "extend and pretend"—prolonging loan terms and reducing interest rates to keep failing enterprises afloat.
This approach mirrors Japan's experience following its economic bubble and subsequent crash in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Japan's prolonged stagnation was largely due to banks avoiding the immediate repercussions of writing off bad loans, opting instead to preserve the illusion of financial health. This strategy, which involved propping up non-viable entities, ultimately undermined Japan's long-term economic viability.
Section 1.2: Assessing Asset Purchases
The effectiveness of asset purchases in revitalizing the economy hinges on whether the assets and their issuers are genuinely facing temporary liquidity issues or are fundamentally insolvent. If the crisis is merely a liquidity panic, central bank purchases can restore order to chaotic markets and prove profitable once stability returns.
However, many Chinese developers and local governments are likely insolvent. With countless apartments left unoccupied and treated as mere storage for wealth instead of homes, there has been extensive overbuilding, particularly in smaller cities and less populated areas. Here, construction became a primary source of employment, and as property values plummeted and construction projects stalled, job losses followed rapidly.
Ultimately, this suggests that bonds and loans from these developers and local governments may be worthless in the long term. Investing in assets from insolvent entities is akin to throwing money away. The CCP is likely aware of this reality and may wish to avoid making significant asset purchases, hoping that time will resolve the issues without necessitating extensive financial expenditure.
Chapter 2: Social Unrest and Economic Consequences
An additional challenge for the CCP is maintaining its image as an infallible governing party. Citizens have traded their freedom and privacy for an improved standard of living. However, the bursting of China's real estate bubble has disrupted this perceived bargain. If the economy continues to falter and citizens grow increasingly impoverished, the CCP may find itself in a precarious position as the social contract disintegrates.
As economic conditions worsen, the CCP will need to allocate more resources to monitor and suppress dissent. This, in turn, will further hinder economic growth, fostering discontent among the populace and creating a vicious cycle.
Section 2.1: The Export Dilemma
This leads to China's most viable option: boosting exports. China has established itself as a crucial part of global supply chains. However, its disregard for intellectual property rights, geopolitical instability, and rising operational costs have made it a less appealing outsourcing destination for foreign companies. While there is potential for China to evolve into an exporter of its own branded goods and services, doing so requires building trust and gaining market share in competitive international markets—a lengthy process that the current leadership may not have the luxury of time to navigate.
In summary, while several strategies exist to enhance China’s economic prospects, significant hurdles remain, casting doubt on their successful implementation.