Exploring "Joan Is Awful": A Critical Look at AI and Deepfakes
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to "Joan Is Awful"
The premiere episode of Season 6 of Black Mirror, featuring Annie Murphy and Salma Hayek, serves as a relevant critique of deepfakes and AI-driven entertainment.
Created by Charlie Brooker, Black Mirror is an anthology series that delves into the darker side of contemporary society, particularly our interaction with technology. This guide explores the themes presented in each episode. After a four-year hiatus, Black Mirror has returned with its sixth season, making its comeback at a pivotal moment.
The inaugural episode of this season, titled "Joan Is Awful," stars Annie Murphy, known for her role in Schitt's Creek, as the central character, Joan, a mid-level manager at a tech firm named Sonicle, who prides herself on being a coffee connoisseur.
On an eventful day, Joan dismisses an employee, Sandy (Ayo Edebiri), and, feeling uncertain, reconnects with an ex-boyfriend, Mac (Rob Delaney). Their meeting leads to a brief kiss, after which Joan returns home to her husband, Krish (Avi Nash).
Following a pleasant dinner and a glass of wine, the couple lounges on the couch and browses Streamberry, a fictional equivalent of Netflix. They stumble upon a new show titled Joan Is Awful, featuring Salma Hayek as Joan, complete with streaked hair reminiscent of the protagonist.
The first episode of this meta-show mirrors the events of Black Mirror, showcasing Joan's life as she raps in her car, fires Sandy, talks about her mundane husband, and receives texts from Mac. Joan is horrified to see her life play out on screen, knowing that her husband will interpret it as reality.
After a heated argument, her husband leaves, leaving Joan in despair as she embarks on a quest to uncover the truth behind this bizarre situation. This quest leads her to consult her lawyer, seek out Salma Hayek, and, in a moment of desperation, desecrate a sacred space.
Video Description: An insightful analysis of "Joan Is Awful," focusing on its themes of identity and the implications of AI-generated entertainment.
Section 1.1: Women and Control Over Their Image
After unexpectedly getting Salma Hayek's attention, the two women discuss their shared predicament.
"I thought I could finally have control over my own image," Salma laments. She reveals her past attempts to communicate with Streamberry, only to be rebuffed.
This sentiment echoes the experiences of many women in the public eye, notably model Emily Ratajkowski, who has spoken out about her inability to prevent a photographer from profiting off unauthorized images of her.
"Men, some of whom I knew well and others I had never met, were debating the ownership of my image," Ratajkowski shared.
Since the rise of the internet, women in the spotlight have faced this challenge. With advancements in technology, deepfakes have become a widespread issue affecting all women, not just celebrities.
Most deepfake content still targets well-known women, but the technology has evolved, making it easier for even internet microcelebrities and ordinary individuals to be victimized by malicious deepfake content.
Section 1.2: The Mechanics of AI-Generated Entertainment
Joan and Salma eventually discover that the show is generated by a quantum computer that collects real-time data to create tailored content. This concept mirrors the K.E.V.I.N. AI from the final episode of She-Hulk, as both serve as creators and manipulators of narratives.
This season of Black Mirror debuted during the Writers Guild of America strike, which began in early May and continues to this day. A central issue in this labor dispute is the impact of streaming on traditional Hollywood structures, alongside concerns about AI's potential to diminish writers' roles.
"Joan Is Awful" portrays a reality where these fears have materialized, suggesting that writers, directors, producers, and other essential crew members may no longer be necessary. This reflects the current media climate, where quantity often trumps quality in content creation.
The episode also critiques algorithms prevalent in social media, which, while not yet creating fully personalized experiences, do curate content designed to engage users—an approach epitomized by TikTok's algorithm.
Creator Charlie Brooker has explained that the show's title stems from the black screen displayed when a phone is off, which reflects the viewer's image. Companies like TikTok aim to prevent such moments of self-reflection.
Chapter 2: Memorable Moments and Details
Video Description: A comprehensive explanation of the plot and themes of "Joan Is Awful," presented in an engaging podcast format.
Salma Hayek's exclamation, "Doesn't my backside have any rights?!" is a standout moment. Additionally, Cate Blanchett's portrayal of Joan in the nested show is a delightful touch. The character of Streamberry's CEO, Mona Javadi, appears to be a nod to Netflix's current Global Head of Television, Bela Bejaria, with the interview she partakes in echoing a recent profile of Bejaria.