# Unraveling the Economics of Intergalactic Commerce—Part I
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Interstellar Trade
In my academic journey, I delved into mathematics and theoretical physics, but my career has largely revolved around economics. This unique blend of disciplines fuels my interest, particularly in Paul Krugman's seminal work, "The Theory of Interstellar Trade" (1978)¹. This paper presents a thought experiment on trade and interest rates in a universe where spaceships can travel at nearly the speed of light.
Traditionally, physics treats time as a constant. However, Einstein’s special relativity reveals that time is more fluid, stretching depending on the observer's velocity. Krugman’s analysis investigates how these relativistic effects influence the time value of money and, consequently, the opportunity costs associated with trading.
This article aims to clarify key elements of special relativity and provide a beginner-friendly overview of Krugman's insights, which can be somewhat complex for those not well-versed in the subject.
Section 1.1: Special Relativity and Time Dilation
Krugman's exploration hinges on how time dilation alters the perception of money's value in trade scenarios. Time dilation is an intriguing phenomenon where two observers perceive time differently based on their relative speeds.
To illustrate, consider this scenario: I remain stationary and observe a train passing at near-light speed. While I experience a full hour, someone aboard the train only perceives a fraction of that time. This discrepancy only becomes significant at extreme velocities, governed by the equation below.
The left side of the equation represents the time experienced by the train passenger, while the right side shows my elapsed hour. The equation accounts for the train's speed (v) and the constant speed of light (c). For instance, if the train travels at one-third the speed of light, the passenger's perceived time is only 56 minutes.
Understanding this phenomenon requires familiarity with Einstein's framework of special relativity, which emphasizes the importance of the observer's perspective when interpreting physical laws. Each observer has a unique reference frame—essentially, how they perceive motion and physical changes.
For example, if I observe a train speeding by, it appears to be in motion while I remain still. In contrast, a passenger on the train perceives themselves as stationary, with the world moving around them. This illustrates the multitude of reference frames available for analyzing a physical scenario.
In physics, the concept of an inertial reference frame is crucial. This stable frame allows for consistent laws of physics across various locations, whether on Earth, Neptune, or anywhere else in the universe. According to Einstein, in an inertial frame, the speed of light remains constant (c = 3 x 10⁸ meters per second), while the speeds of other objects may differ depending on the observer's location.
Section 1.2: The Implications of Time Dilation
The constancy of light's speed leads to profound implications: time is not a uniform measure but varies based on relative motion. To delve deeper, let’s consider two observers in different frames of reference.
Assume we are at rest on a platform observing a moving object. We can record its position at two different times, allowing us to calculate an 'invariant interval' to describe the object's motion.
If we shift to a frame moving with the object, we note different time and spatial coordinates, yet the invariant intervals remain consistent, as Einstein demonstrated. This leads us to the time dilation formula, revealing that a fast-moving observer experiences less passage of time relative to a stationary one.
Chapter 2: Economic Models in Interplanetary Trade
In Krugman's analysis, he presents a hypothetical trade scenario between two planets, which I will simplify to Earth and Mars. Imagine two types of goods—Earth goods and Martian goods—each with fixed prices in their respective markets, utilizing a common currency like the US dollar.
In economic terms, we often refer to a 'risk-free' interest rate, representing the return on government bonds—debt instruments that yield annual payments until maturity. Assuming a stable government, this rate is regarded as risk-free, allowing investors to predict returns over time.
In this intergalactic merchant scenario, one would purchase Earth goods, travel to Mars (incurring transportation costs), sell the goods at Martian prices, and return to Earth to sell Martian goods at Earth prices.
To evaluate profitability, we must consider the initial costs involved in acquiring the goods and their transportation. The revenue generated from these transactions will depend significantly on the time taken for the trip and the opportunity cost of not investing the capital in government bonds during that time.
Section 2.1: The Role of Time Dilation in Profitability
Time dilation becomes critical in assessing trade profitability. For instance, if the journey to Mars takes N years as perceived from Earth, the merchant’s experience may differ due to time dilation, resulting in a shorter elapsed time for them.
Consequently, the opportunity cost of capital invested in government bonds diminishes if the merchant experiences a shorter timeframe. This dynamic creates a more favorable condition for profit as it reduces the effective cost of the investment.
If government officials accompany the merchant, they too will experience time dilation, allowing for compounded returns on their investments over a reduced timeframe. This aspect suggests that trade could be incentivized if the government adjusts its economic measures based on the merchant's time perspective rather than Earth’s.
In Krugman's work, he posits that the optimal economic model incorporates these time-related factors, providing a foundation for further exploration in future discussions.
Conclusion: Bridging Physics and Economics
This overview serves as an introduction to the fascinating interplay between relativistic physics and economic theory. Krugman's paper offers a wealth of insights that warrant deeper exploration, which I hope to address in subsequent articles. Stay tuned for more discussions on this captivating topic!
References
[1] Paul Krugman, 2010. "The Theory Of Interstellar Trade," Economic Inquiry, Western Economic Association International, vol. 48(4), pages 1119–1123, October.